Skip to main content

Creating Effective Knockout Questions

Learn to set up knockout questions that automatically filter candidates based on essential requirements, saving you valuable screening time.

Sean Griffith avatar
Written by Sean Griffith
Updated over a month ago

Creating Effective Knockout Questions in Truffle

Knockout questions are your first line of defense in filtering candidates. They automatically screen out applicants who don't meet your minimum requirements, saving you valuable time and ensuring you only review qualified candidates.

What Are Knockout Questions?

Knockout questions are pass/fail questions that candidates must answer correctly to proceed with their application. If a candidate doesn't meet your specified criteria, they're automatically filtered out from the audio screening stage.

How Truffle's AI Creates Knockout Questions

Truffle analyzes multiple sources to generate ideal knockout questions for your role:

  • Your job description details

  • Information from your intake questionnaire

  • Industry-specific standards and requirements

  • Role-based best practices from thousands of successful hires

Important: The AI-recommended knockout questions are carefully calibrated for your specific position. For best results, accept the suggested questions as presented. You should only edit them if there's a critical requirement that was missed.

Types of Knockout Questions in Truffle

Truffle supports three types of knockout questions:

1. Yes/No Questions

  • Best for: Work authorization, certification requirements, willingness to travel, etc.

  • Example: "Are you legally authorized to work in the United States?"

  • Pass Criteria: Must answer "Yes"

2. Numeric Questions

  • Best for: Salary requirements, years of experience, etc.

  • Example: "What is your minimum salary requirement?"

  • Pass Criteria: Less than or equal to your maximum budget (e.g., $50,000)

3. Select Questions

  • Best for: Experience levels, specific qualifications with multiple acceptable options

  • Example: "How many years of sales experience do you have?"

  • Pass Criteria: Selecting from acceptable options (e.g., "3-5 years" or "5+ years")

How Many Knockout Questions Should You Use?

Finding the right balance is important for effective candidate screening:

  • Recommended number: 3-5 knockout questions

  • Maximum limit: 8 knockout questions

Using too few questions may not adequately filter candidates, while too many can create excessive barriers and candidate drop-off. The sweet spot of 3-5 questions typically allows you to cover essential requirements without creating a cumbersome application process.

Creating Strategic Question Sets

Your knockout questions should work together as a cohesive screening system:

Progressive Filtering

Start with broader requirements that apply to all candidates (like work authorization), then proceed to more specific role requirements.

Complementary Coverage

Each question should address a different essential requirement. Make sure your questions collectively cover all true must-haves for the role.

Logical Flow

Order your questions in a way that makes sense to candidates, typically from most general to most specific.

Avoid Redundancy

Each question should serve a distinct purpose. Avoid asking for the same information in multiple ways.

Impact on the Candidate Journey

Understanding how knockout questions affect your hiring pipeline is crucial:

  • Automatic Audio Screening Invitations: Only candidates who pass all knockout questions are automatically invited to complete the audio screening interview

  • Application Storage: All applications are stored in your Truffle dashboard, even those that don't pass knockout criteria

  • Manual Invitations: You can still review all applications and manually invite candidates to the audio screener if you identify promising applicants who didn't pass a knockout question

  • Quality Focus: Truffle's goal is to present only highly qualified candidates for your immediate consideration, saving you time while preserving your access to the full candidate pool

Compliance and Legal Considerations

When creating knockout questions, it's essential to ensure they comply with employment laws and don't inadvertently discriminate against protected groups:

Guidelines for Compliant Questions

  • Focus on job-relevant qualifications and requirements

  • Avoid questions that could reveal protected characteristics (age, race, gender, religion, etc.)

  • Ensure questions relate directly to the ability to perform essential job functions

  • Be consistent in how you apply knockout criteria to all candidates

Structured Question Format

Truffle uses structured knockout questions with defined pass/fail criteria rather than open-ended responses. This approach helps maintain consistency and compliance.

Note: For more detailed guidance on legal compliance in your candidate screening process, see our article on [Legal Compliance and Privacy in Candidate Screening].

Testing and Optimizing Your Knockout Questions

Monitoring and improving your knockout questions is key to an effective hiring process:

Monitoring Pass/Fail Rates

If more than 80-90% of candidates are failing your knockout questions, your criteria may be too strict. Conversely, if almost everyone passes, your questions may not be effectively filtering.

Reviewing Filtered Candidates

Periodically check applications that didn't pass your knockout criteria to ensure you're not missing potentially qualified candidates.

Refining Your Approach

Be prepared to adjust your knockout questions based on:

  • Candidate quality in your screening stage

  • Changes in job requirements

  • Shifts in the hiring market

  • Feedback from your hiring team

Note: For more strategies on testing and optimization, see our article on [Testing and Optimizing Your Candidate Screening Process].

Role-Specific Knockout Questions

Different positions require different types of knockout questions. While Truffle's AI will recommend questions based on your specific role, here are some general principles:

Technical Positions

Focus on required technical skills, certifications, or experience with specific tools or technologies.

Customer-Facing Roles

Consider experience levels, communication capabilities, and schedule availability.

Management Positions

Emphasize leadership experience, team size managed, and specific industry knowledge.

Entry-Level Positions

Focus on education, basic skills, and willingness to learn rather than extensive experience.

Note: For specific examples and best practices tailored to common roles, see our article on [Role-Specific Knockout Questions: Examples and Best Practices].

Best Practices

  • Trust the AI Recommendations: Truffle's suggested questions are based on comprehensive analysis of your specific needs

  • Focus on True Requirements: Only use knockout questions for genuine must-haves

  • Be Specific and Clear: Word questions precisely so candidates understand exactly what you're asking

  • Limit the Number: Use 3-5 knockout questions for optimal results

  • Consider Legal Implications: Ensure your questions comply with employment laws

  • Review Regularly: Update knockout questions as job requirements evolve

  • Test Your Approach: Monitor if your questions are filtering appropriately

  • Balance Strictness: Be careful not to make requirements so strict that you miss good candidates

  • Consider Alternatives: For some skills, be open to equivalent experience rather than exact matches

Remember, knockout questions determine which candidates automatically advance to your audio screening stage. They're designed to filter out clearly unqualified candidates so you can focus on evaluating those with the highest potential, while still giving you access to all applicants through your dashboard.

Did this answer your question?